Caliban is a childlike and in many ways childish native of the enchanted island where Prospero lives with his daughter, Miranda. The offspring of the witch Sycorax, Caliban was formerly treated generously by Prospero, who arrived on Caliban’s island twelve years earlier, teaching him to speak Prospero’s own language and even giving Caliban wine to drink. However, when Caliban proved himself irresponsible and a threat to Miranda, Prospero confined Caliban to one part of the island.
As a character, Caliban deserves our sympathy. And yet, although he is not a villain, he is not a wholly sympathetic character either. He readily confesses to trying to rape Miranda, Prospero’s daughter (in II.2), although given the fact that he expresses no contrition over this, ‘confesses’ is not quite the word. Indeed, he wishes he had been able to carry out the deed, so he could people the whole ‘isle with Calibans’ (what a thought!).
According to Caliban himself, also in II.2, Prospero originally showed Caliban some kindness, even giving him some wine (presumably this is what the ‘Water with berries in’t’ refers to). Prospero says he only confined Caliban to a ‘hard rock’ on the island after Caliban’s attempt to have his way with Miranda.
Nevertheless, Caliban is a character who has not been dealt a good hand in life. His mother, Sycorax, is dead, and the god she worshipped, Setebos, is no match for Prospero’s magic. This is one reason why Caliban allows himself to suffer being Prospero’s slave: there is no chance of escape. Caliban resents Prospero for confining him to one part of the island, but he also resents him for the kindnesses the magician showed him: Prospero taking the time to teach Caliban his language, for instance, has only succeeded in giving Caliban the means to curse his miserable lot using new words. It hasn’t actually improved his lot.
Yet when Stephano appears, with wine, Caliban foolishly believes that Stephano could seriously usurp Prospero and take control of the island. He’s clearly naïve and silly for thinking this: if Setebos is no match for Prospero’s magic, one hardly thinks a drunken butler would present much of a threat. Nevertheless, in recent decades many critics have analysed Caliban’s character in light of postcolonialism, seeing Prospero as the white oppressor using his more powerful position (his books and his magic) to subjugate the native Caliban and proclaim himself ruler of the island.
Such an analysis of Caliban’s character, whereby he becomes the oppressed native and Prospero is the heavy-handed European coloniser, does map well onto Shakespeare’s text in some ways, although it’s worth bearing in mind that he is not just a colonised native, and such a reading runs the risk of limiting what Shakespeare is doing with the character of Caliban in the play. For, as Harold Bloom has pointed out in Shakespeare: The Invention Of The Human
I’ve always found Caliban to be a problematic character, and feel like the mix of his savagery and his “innocent, childlike, and naïve” nature both demonstrate that colonial type mindset toward indigenous populations the world over.
I agree with you, Oliver, in that Caliban is no saint. However, i strongly agree with Shaun in that the attitude towards Caliban represents a colonial mindset – “child- like ” in many ways a childish native”. Read Kipling’s poem, “The White Man’s Burden”, and you will see how colonial powers regarded the peoples they subjugated. It was the duty of the colonial powers to “take care” of the poor, dark, ignorant ones under their rule.
I would like to see you discuss Mary Shelley’s creature in Frankenstein. I believe that over the years readers have begun to sympathize with the creature, certainly not with Victor Frankenstein. The creature is in some ways like Caliban – outcast by society.
What an interesting article – yet for all his childlike character, he has the most beautiful, poetical words in the play regarding his love for the island…